Friday, September 25, 2015

Star Wars The Clone Wars: Season 1

First time here? Check out the mission statement here, then get caught up on the canon with Episode I here, Episode II here and the Clone Wars film here.


The year was...not really worth mentioning. In trying to figure out the format for writing up television shows, especially since these series were release fairly close to present day, the tone-setting nostalgia trips have fallen to the wayside for now (though for those wondering, the season debuted Oct. 3rd, 2008 and wrapped Mar. 20, 2009).  So with 484 minutes worth of material to cover (as opposed to the usual 120 or so), we might as well just dive right into it.

Obviously, spoilers below for the first season of Star Wars: The Clone Wars (and therefor the film, and everything that precedes it) so proceed with caution.



The series kicks off with Ambush, an episode never intended to be the premiere, either before or after Lucas excised some episodes to make the feature film, but it serves as a fine enough introduction to the series and it's style. After its jarring debut in the feature film, the new theme song feels more natural here, and the quick logo shot into the episode's moral (reminiscent of the meditations on war often presented before missions in COD: Modern Warfare) set a good tone for what we're about to see: An anthology series; stories of war and the battlefield, parables and allegories of conflicts and conscience that can get surprisingly profound for a show with such a kiddish atmosphere (an atmosphere mostly set through the rather ill-fitting Tom Kane voice-over, though I'd grown used to it by the series' end). Where in the timeline this takes place, we're unsure, as the series has a strange chronology Wookiepedia can clear up for the curious, but somewhere along the line, Yoda and Asajj Ventress have both converged on the moon of Rugosa to try and convince the king of the Toyadrian system to join their side of the conflict (fun fact: Watto the junk dealer from Episode I is a Toyadrian, except he didn't have the attire or weaponry of those depicted in this episode because even George knew how to pull back on the arab/semitic characters a bit). Ventures lands first, as Separatist forces have attacked Yoda's ship, forcing him and three troopers to take escape pod to the surface while the ship flees (at one point, one battle droid complains to another about his aim at the pod, and he responds "Oh Well, it's my programming". I really shouldn't enjoy the battledroid schtick as much as I do, but god I love it). Via hologram, Yoda contacts the king to ensure the monarch he is still willing to negotiate an alliance, and Ventress puts forward a deal: Should Yoda prove formidable against her best droids, then Toyadaria joins the Republic, but should they fail, Toyadaria joins the Separatists.

The king accepts the proposal, and Yoda and his team soon face off against a troop battalion, and flee into a cave, outnumbered disheartened. Fitting the moral of the episode ("Great leaders inspire greatness in others"), Yoda explains to the troopers that it's not their weapons but their minds that make them powerful, and that in the end they are individuals, no matter what their origins, inspiring his troops not only to be better warriors, but to be themselves.

He then proceeds to massacre the ungodly hell out of a whole slew of battledroids, at one point getting inside a tank, from which point on his actions can only be determined by flickers of green glow and the droids which are drawn into the tank who never come out. It's a truly inspired piece of Star Wars visual, and sets the bar much higher for this series than it's feature film debut did in just a matter of moments. After some droideka are taken out by newly inspired clone troopers, the king has seen enough and decides to support the Republic. Disappointed, Ventress is ordered by Count Dooku to kill the king, but Yoda arrives on the scene just in time to halt Asajj with the power of the force, taking away her lightsabers. Yet, rather than execute her, or even command the troops to arrest her, he hands her back her blades, at which point she triggers and explosion and flees as gunships arrive to retrieve the group.

Overall, it's a charming little episode, light but entertaining, and far better than the film which preceded it, though it took me some time to come around on the finally. Initially I was a bit frustrated with the "Yoda giving her back her weapons with enough time for her to flee" sequence, finding it contrived, until it struck me that this wasn't just some beat put into the script to buy time. If Anakin were there, or Dooku or Grievous, they would have executed their enemy on the spot. Even Obi-Wan or Windu would have immediately called for her arrest. But Yoda wouldn't. He would give her her blades back. He would want her to see that she'd been bested, to recognize her defeat with honor and humility, and surrender. He wanted to give her a chance to hand herself over, to perhaps seek penance and redemption. Because that's what Yoda does, and this series gets Yoda, even better than the prequel trilogy did. And that's the point where I became on board for this whole series.


Next up was a three part series (Rising Malevolence, Shadow of Malevolence, and Destroy Malevolence) focused on General Grievous' new weapon, the eponymous ship. Jedi Master (and all around stoic badass) Plo Koon locates the ship and seeks reinforcements, but i contacting Anakin finds the other Jedi have been instructed otherwise. Before he can seek help elsewhere, General Grievous (in our first proper encounter with him) jams his communications and attacks, forcing Plo and his team to flee into escape pods. Anakin, upon consulting the Jeci council who command him to stay defending the supply lines, is seemingly as resigned to Plo's fate as Plo himself is, but his padawan Ahsoka refuses to just let Koon drift in space until his ultimate demise. Whether he has a change of heart through Ahsoka's pleading, or his rebellious streak had kicked in at being commanded to ignore a person in need and this was his plan all along, Anakin and Ahsoka go off after Plo Koon rather than follow orders, and are almost immediately confronted with an image of grim death. And not just a vague shot of, like, a hand and leaving it up to the viewer's imagination. Nope, a full on wide shot of an escape pod, with windows blown open, and a dead human body draped over one of the frames. And that, that would be the point where you'd say "Huh, that's a little grim for a show on the Cartoon Network" and move on if you weren't later treated to a sequence of a battle droid actually cutting open the windows of another pod, causing the vacuum of space to rip the clones from the vessels, suffocating them, and causing their lifeless bodies to drift among the debris. That right there is some heavy s**t. A team of droids find Koon and his pod, and Plo manages to find them off before Anakin and Ahsoka arrive for the rescue, and he tells them of Malevolence and it's ion cannon, and after attempting to shut down every detectable piece of their ship and blend in with the debris (forgetting the medical droid, whose faint signal tips off the Separatists to their whereabouts), they hyperspace-jump back to base, where Anakin and Ahsoka await admonishment for disobeying the council's orders, content in the knowledge that they saved a life.

Some time later, Anakin, Ahsoka and Plo lead a charge against Malevolence with a fleet of Y-wings and discover it plans to attack the Kaliida Shoals medical center, a Republic medical station on the outer rim. Anakin wants to go for an all out assault, but Ahsoka and Plo Koon caution him that his plan is too aggressive. After navigating an old smuggler's route called the Balmorra Run and the loss of a good chunk of Anakin's squadron (even a clone named Matchstick they get yo attached to just to break your heart), it turns out Anakin was right, his strategy does work, forcing the Malevolence to retreat.

In his retreat, Grievous' ship (through the machinations of Count Dooku and Darth Sidious) crosses paths with a ship carrying Senator Amidala and C-3PO to a negotiation. Trapping her in a tractor beam, Grievous holds Padme hostage, and though she begs the Republic to continue their attacks on the ship and worry not about her, Anakin demands they stage a rescue. There's some explosions, some romantic interlude, none of which is of any real consequence until, in their final moments before fleeing the ship, Anakin rigs the nav computer of the Malevolence to crash directly into a moon, and though Grievous manages to escape, the Separatist's ultimate weapon is destroyed.

Ultimately not much comes from this arc. We get to see a much more cunning and engaging Anakin than we got in the prequels, likely finally conveyed in the manner Lucas failed to in his writing, and there are some flickers of really quality moments, like the menacing General Grievous or the pretty palpable romance between Anakin and Padme (including a cute little exchange of “Ever since I’ve known you, you’ve been playing with droids” “I used to put them together, now I take them apart” which is a hell of a lot better than "I don't like sand", let me tell you), but overall this feels like a one or maybe two episode storyline stretched out over three episodes, and with the clear set-up for an anthology series where you can jump all over the galaxy and it's timeline, and a great example of a self-contained episode with Yoda preceding it, this three-parter sets a worrisome tone that the series will be bogged down by over-long arcs to fill the holes where episodes were plucked by Lucas to make his film.


Thankfully, we're immediately thereafter treated to a delightful one off, Rookies, that introduces us to the heart of the series: not Anakin or Ahsoka, nor anyone we've known from the saga so far, but rather the clones themselves. Blending the tones of Platoon and Stripes for a romping "war is hell" affair, any episode focused on the clone troopers themselves is a series highlight, and from the moment we're faded into troopers listening to the "Republic Radio", you half expect "Fortunate Son" to be playing while they smoke cigarettes and play cards. Frustrated that their station is so far removed from the action, rookies Fives, Hevy, Echo and Cutup are chastised by Sergeant O'Niner to remember that their job as look outs is crucial to ensure there's no surprise separatist attack, and as though on cue, shortly thereafter a fleet of battledroids show up for a surprise attack, executing some of the troopers, including O'Niner. Fives, Hevy, Echo and Cutup escape, only for Cutup to be almost immediately swallowed up by a Rishi Eel as soon as they exit the facility. The remaining troopers, after discovering communication through normal channels has been rendered impossible, decide to send up a flare in a last ditch effort. 

Commander's Rex and Cody, visiting the facility for an inspection, are thrown by the strange demeanor of the clones they encounter (saying "Roger Roger" is not a good way to pretend you're not a battle droid, turns out), and after seeing the signal flare, the two realize what's happened and take out the nearest disguised droid before being overwhelmed by an onslaught and escaping into the same cater which contains the rookies. Together, they devise a plan to take out the base entirely rather than let it fall once more into separatist hands, as conquering it would allow the Separatists easy access to the cloning facility on Kamino, effectively wiping out the Republic's main battle resource. After setting the charges, the troops flee, but Hevy is unable to arm them remotely, and charges in to activate them manually, giving his life for the cause. After morning the loss of their friend, who'd been the most adamant about wanting to "see action" before it all went down, Fives and Echo are inducted into the prestigious 501st legion by Commander Rex.


In the two-parter Downfall of a Droid and Duel of the Droids...alright, Anakin loses R2-D2, has to go recover it because he never wiped it's memory, and therefor R2 contains Republic plans that can't fall into Separatist hands. Anakin is also weirdly attached to R2. Ashoka accompanies him in tracking down R2, accompanied by a new R3 unit that continually screws things up, and Anakin is routinely verbally abusive to (but don't feel bad, cause that droid's a Separatist spy anyway). After contending with a droid dealer who tries and fails to trap them, the team wind up aboard General Grievous' ship where they rescue R2. That's about it. Not a whole hell of a lot going on beyond an entertaining fight between R2 and R3, and certainly not enough to warrant a two-parter (the "droid dealer entrapping them" segment feels so blatantly like padding). From Anakin being able to recognize R2 from his "voice" to him just kinda being mildly peeved this R3 betrayed him (You know, the guy that slaughtered countless Tusken Raiders), the episodes feel so generic, and do nothing to flesh out the characters within them, and so just purposefully drift along like a suffocated clone trooper in space (I know, too soon).


Ok, two things to know right off that bat: Yes, as the title implies, the episode Bombad Jedi is about Jar Jar Binks, and no, it's actually not insufferable. I know, I know. I had my trepidations as well. The minute we see him aboard Amidala's Rodia-bound ship, my notes just read "Holy s**t, it's ****ing Jar Jar, and god damn it, he's already bumbling. This could go south so fast. Also, he has a tie". And indeed, a tie he does have. But despite a few early bumbles causing Padme to ask Jar Jar to stay behind for the negotiations (why bring him at all, then?) and some more irksomely drastic bumbles afterwards (he smashes the ship, which is probably a moment where those already full of ire towards the gungan just turned it off), Jar Jar actually proves a bit of his worth this episode (and credit needs to be given to Ahmet Best for always giving it his all, no matter what he's handed).

After Padme's Rodian relative betrays her due to Nute Gunray's stranglehold on Rodia's access to food and other necessities (that's right, children. Resource manipulation and poverty cause people to do terrible things. Clone Wars: It's like Captain Phillips for kids!), Jar Jar decides to rescue her by donning a Jedi's cloak that's been stashed away in Padme's ship, which I suppose is Anakin's answer to leaving a toothbrush at her place. The Separatist forces are so intimidated by the idea of a Jedi that they never question whether he has the abilities the costume denotes (because some writer apparently watched The Three Amigos before this pitch meeting), and tossing in Jar Jar's ability to commune with sea creatures he apparently has, he's able to help rescue Padme, who does a pretty good job saving herself employing a Goldfinger-esque tactic to lure the guard droids into her cell to facilitate an escape. They arrest Gunray, Palpatine sends supply ships to Rhoda, and the most loathed character in cinema now becomes the Aquaman of the Star Wars universe (which, in his case, is a step up).

The follow-up episode to Bombad Jedi, Cloak of Darkness, has a much more dour tone than its predecessor, as Jedi Master Luminary Unduli and Ahsoka are tasked with bringing Nute Gunray to trial. Greeted upon their landing by a assemblage of masked, faceless Senate Commandos, and one without a helmet (who you call from the beginning is gonna be a traitor because, well, Chekhov's lightsaber and all), Nute Gunray is taken away to away that the two Jedi might interrogate him. Ashoka employs a "bad cop" routine to counter Luminara's calm demeanor, which the Jedi master doesn't approve of, when the base is infiltrated by vulture droids, forcing Luminary to leave Ahsoka alone to guard Gunray while she tries to fend them off. Gurney attempts to throw Ahsoka off her game by pointing out the lack of faith Luminara has in her (Gunray is a lot less iritating in this series than the films, and his accent far less a caricature), when unbeknownst to either of them Asajj Ventress emerges onto the base, determined to rescue or silence the imprisoned Viceroy. After wiping out a slew of clones and making her way to Gunray's holding cell, she spars with Ahsoka until Luminara returns. Now outnumbered, Ventress sets off an explosion to rock the ship and escapes. Luminara follows, ignoring Ahsoka's warnings that Asajj is too powerful for one Jedi to take on alone. Of course, she's right, and Luminara is soon overpowered. Ashoka leaves the Commandos in charge of Gunray and rescues the Jedi master, but in her absence, ol' one-Commando-whose-face-we-saw betrays the rest and frees Gunray, escaping on a ship with Ventress, only to be stabbed clean through the chest, in full view for all the kids to see, after he tells Ventress he plans to take most of the credit for the rescue. Yep, this show goes hard. And the next portion of this three-parter goes even harder.

You see, I'm not gonna tell you the plot to Lair of Grievous is great. It's not that memorable, and in terms of overall storytelling, it's a bit of fluff, since Gunray isn't even at the lair after all. But the beauty of the episode is it's tone, it's atmosphere and the dark places it's willing to go. Kit Fisto is reunited with his former apprentice Nahdar Vebb, only to find him lacking the kind of calm judgement necessary of a Jedi. Thinking they've found Nute Gunray, they stumble instead upon a hologram of Count Dooku, offering them an "alternative prize". It seems Dooku is displeased with Grievous, and has determined that this set-up will either inspire Grievous to eliminate more Jedi and take more command, or do the Separatists the favor of removing the dead weight. I could break down the plot points, but beyond "they fight a giant monster" and "they fight Grievous", there's little point in delving into them, even if it means ignoring Grievous' sassy Billy Eichner-esque companion droid, A-4D. Suffice it to say, the highlight of this episode is when Vebb goes up against Grievous, attempting as Fisto would later put it, to "match Grievous' power with his own", and he gets straight up, in your face murdered by Grievous. Now, mind you, Vebb has been played pretty young in this episode, and is very likely a teenager, at most maybe 20 or so. That right there sets the tone for the show. That, on a much smaller and less significant scale, is their Game of Thrones S1E9. They're gonna kill people. Not just clones, or robots, but Jedi. Young Jedi. Anyone is fair game, don't matter that this is on Cartoon Network. If you didn't see them in Revenge of the Sith or after, there's no guarantee they're coming out of this series ok, and that alone would make this pretty worthwhile three-parter worth the watch.


Apparently the Nute Gunray affair, spanning three episodes and still unresolved, has been abandoned at this point (or this two-parter happens before or far after in the chronology) in favor of an attempt to capture Count Dooku in Dooku Captured. We're told through the voice-over that Anakin made an attempt to capture the Count that apparently didn't warrant being seen by us at home (apparently there was an online comic depicting it that tied into the episode, yet it's no longer canon because reasons), and that he's subsequently gone missing. Obi-Wan goes to rescue him, and through turn of events both the ship carrying Dooku and the vessel with Obi-Wan and the newly recovered Anakin crash land on the planet Vanqor. After a brief skirmish with the Count that leaves the two Jedi stranded in a cave (where they use lightsabers for illumination, a pretty novel idea we haven't seen put to use thus far in the canon, obvious as it seems), Dooku is captured by a band of pirates (who listen to straight up Indo-African almost Bollywood-esque music, and they're impoverished drunken pirates, but I've already made one Captain Phillips reference this post, so I won't bring it up again. S**t I love that movie. Anyway...). The main pirate, voiced by terror who flaps in the night Jim Cummings, offers to sell Dooku to the Republic, who at the urging of Senator Amidala send Obi-Wan and Anakin to ensure the Count is truly captured. Agreeing to go unarmed because it's not like these are ****ing pirates or anything, they find Dooku alive and well (suspended the exact same way he'd once suspended Obi-Wan in Attack of the Clones), but he urges them to have caution and not underestimate the pirates which is both common sense and a weird thing to warn the people you'd very much like to see dead. After informing the council that Dooku is there, Palpatine dispatches a Senator along with the ever-bumbling Representative Binks (at least this makes sense, as Palpatine wants this to go awry) to the planet, while Anakin and Obi-Wan are invited to....alright let's just do this. The pirates tell Obi-Wan and Anakin to come to a celebratory banquet that they can't refuse and are served drugged drinks which they switch with the guys next to them because that just has to happen in every adventure story at some point. No matter how long, long ago Star Wars takes place, this was cliched even then.

The Gungan General, of course, renders the final scene of the last episode pointless, since Obi-Wan and Anakin apparently were drugged anyway, in some fashion we never saw, because...this is about the point the episode loses me, honestly. You guys know where this is going. The two Jedi and Dooku have to work together to escape, you know, The Defiant Ones, while Jar Jar (who is not voiced by Ahmet Best, which is more distressing than it should be) bumbles his way into being a general. Quite frankly, aside from a totally badass sequence of Count Dooku force-strangling a pirate while making him shoot another pirate with a blaster, and the fact that I will watch anything that involves Jim Cummings (and yes, I mean anything), the only thing of significance about this trite filler of an episode is that it is the inaugural entry into a long sequence of trite filler episodes (save one bright spot) before we get to the finale, so let's just charge through this and not linger.


So, first up at bat is a two-parter that has no business being a two parter, Jedi Crash and Defenders of Peace. Here, we're introduced to a planet of pacifist space lemurs with Scottish accents. The young want to pick a side, while the wise old leader of the tribe advises them to keep to their neutral, peaceful posture or risk wiping out everything they've created. They want to survive, but he'd rather the civilization be wiped out having stood for something substantial than rob themselves of their values just to stay alive, and believes that at the end of the day, refusing to fight back is its own form of resistance. What an ***hole, right? I mean, pacifists are such p***ies, right? I mean, at least that's the takeaway from this episode. Hell, the moral at the beginning of Defenders of Peace is "When surrounded by war, one must eventually choose a side", which is kind of an insane message when you think about it. I mean, that would make sense if they were too scared to fight, sure. Like, if these were rebels trying to recruit people to fight the Empire, and these guys were the type who'd rather keep their head down and survive than fight for freedom, sure, that'd make sense. That'd be in line with the ideal of Star Wars, the heroism of standing for something other than yourself. But here, we're meant to chastise the old man for being willing to die for an ideal instead of just doing whatever's necessary to survive? In the end, the Scotsmonkeys do defend themselves, and the wise old man of the tribe even suggests it was the right course of action, but seeing the Republic ships flying over head, wonders at what cost.

The next episode, Trespass...I'm gonna be 100% honest with you, I had to hit Wookiepedia to even remember anything about this episode beyond the fact that the episode contained "a blue alien dude who reminded me of that one Daft Punk video" (my one note about the episode). Clearly forgettable, this far-more-Trek-than-Wars episode where the sentient but animalistic creatures of a planet are at constant conflict with blue humanoid moon creatures. The old guard refuse to let the conflict end, where the younger people, particularly Senator Riyu Chuchi, want to see the conflict end. Eventually, Riyu's superior, Chairman Chi Cho (the names in this episode, all these names, they're a thing now) takes a spear to the back, dying due to his own warmongering, and peace is brokered. Also, Anakin and Obi-Wan are there, because **** it, why not, right?

Good, that's done. I'm not gonna say this is the last time the season fumbles. Trust me, save a couple of bright spots from here on out, it feels all fumbles. But when it does pull it off, this isn't just some run of the mill touchdown. When the show's good, it's David Tyree helmet catch amazing. So let's get there.


Look at Ventress up there. She looks like a Reboot villain, and I mean that in the best way. Everything is just on point in The Hidden Enemy, from it's lighting to it's dialogue to it's John Carpenter's The Thing-esque paranoia. I had my concerns when this was revealed to be a prequel to the film, which brought us back to the dreadfully named Christophsis, but the level of intrigue and sense of claustrophobia elevated this episode to a whole different plane from the film (or indeed, any of the prequel films, I'll go so far as to say). When the Republic's battle strategy collapses after a droid battalion shifts tactics, as though anticipating what the Republic had had planned, they steal the head of a command tactical droid and analyze it. It only reveals that the Separatists knew of their plans in advance before malfunctioning, and Obi-Wan decides to confide in Cody and Rex that they intend to sneak behind emery lines to determine how they're receiving the intel, but advise Rex and Cody to keep their departure a secret, in case there's a mole. They concur, but after the Jedi leave, Cody finds a comlink left open in the room, meaning someone was eavesdropping on the conversation. They find an unidentifiable figure outside the room and give chase, but lose him within the mess hall. Realizing the room is only full of clones, they know that there is indeed a mole, and it's one of their own. They search the communications records and find a low unusual frequency coming from the barracks of Sergeant Slick and his men, and from here the episode plays out like if The Thing was an espionage thriller set during Vietnam, and then remade to be in space, and it's exactly as awesome as that sounds.

Rex and Cody proceed to interrogate all of Slick's men, and while Jester, Punch, Sketch and Gus all have solid alibis, Chopper is being noticeably cagey, and is soon the focus of great suspicion, until he reveals that he's been collecting trophies of his kills, namely droid fingers he'd made into a necklace (and if you're wondering the origin of such a colorful bit of character trait comes from, google Sam Ybarra. In fact, I'll do it for you. Yep, this was on Cartoon Network). Slick still feels suspicious of Chopper and demands a full investigation when the Jedi return, overplaying his hand as Cody quickly realizes no one knows of the Jedi's departure beyond himself, Rex, and whoever was on the other end of the comlink. Knowing the jig is up, fights off Cody and Chopper, fleeing the scene and using charges he'd set to blow up the weapons depot and several ships. After it's revealed Slick made his way to the command center, Rex and Cody command the others to guard the perimeter, choosing to take Slick on themselves strategically than risk more loss of resources through a full on assault.

Obi-Wan and Anakin, the subject of much observation from Separatist spy droids, swiftly realize their attempt at espionage has been foiled, but trudge on, encountering Asajj Ventress (but clearly not for the first time, still leaving us unsatisfied canonically as to their original encounter). In one of the most exciting fights of the series thus far, Obi-Wan and Anakin seemingly win the duel, but Ventress cuts through the floor and flees. The Jedi catch up to her and skirmish once more, but upon seeing the vast droid army Ventress has amassed, escape to prepare for the oncoming onslaught.

Observing the empty command center, Rex and Cody surmise that lick is in the air vents, and conduct an pantomime to lure him out, with Rex seemingly leaving the room, and Cody placing his gun on the table. Slick takes the bait, and finds the weapon empty, as Rex places his (far less empty) weapon at Slick's head. Slick manages to fight them off briefly but is eventually subdued and brought before the returning Jedi, where he unleashes a vitriolic rant to reveal his motivations, and makes one of the most impassioned arguments against the Clone Wars ever presented in the canon, with some of the most thought-provoking writing in the entire series:

"It's the Jedi who keep my brothers enslaved. We do your bidding, we serve at your whim. I just wanted something more...I love my brothers. You're too blind to see it, but I was striking a blow for all clones."
Now, it seems silly to empathize with a cartoon clone, yes. But think about it, cause at it's core, this is some Ender's Game, Heinlein-level sci-fi existentialism. This is the first clone to come along thus far who realize how ****ed up it is that they're literally cloned to kill. It's like a draft, except they never had a life before the service. They're literally robbed of a childhood, robbed of their innocence, forced to fight, to serve and die at the command of the Jedi, with no hope of getting free, no alternative. And knowing through hindsight that loyal service to the Republic would mean the eventual slaughter of all  the Jedi, including massacring children, and becoming servants to a tyranical emperor, while eventually being phased out in favor of volunteers, dying either on the battlefield or obsolete, with no real name, nothing, no shred of individual identity to live on after your borrowed body finally gives up the ghost; knowing all that, whose to say he really was so wrong?

Yeah, that's some good ****ing sci-fi right there. It doesn't get much better than that, and these next few episodes don't come close, so let's just get a move on shall we? Ok, we can linger on The Hidden Enemy just a little longer, to soak in this great featurette (and learn to appreciate Lucas as an idea man just a little bit more).


The one good thing about the two-parter Blue Shadow Virus and Mystery of a Thousand Moons (besides getting more Padme and Ahsoka, which I'm now always on board for) is the aesthetic, a blend of Fleischer and Geiger, which gives moments a sense of if Flash Gordon met Alien (see above image for example). Beyond that, this bottle episode about a deadly virus is weighed down by cliched story beats, an insufferably cartoonish mad scientist and a general lack of stakes. You don't really care if the clones die (you heartless bastards, what would Slick say?), you know damn well Padme makes it out since she can't die until she's had kids (but she can die immediately after), and some folks would be stoked if Jar Jar croaked (and until Ahmed Best is back as the voice, I'm with ya), so really the only one we're worried about is Ahsoka. Surprise, surprise, by the way: they survive. After Anakin journeys to a far off planet to find a magical root that can cure them, and encountering a typically grating Amblin kid and his village of superstitious people, Anakin returns with the root and saves the day. The only good piece of character development that comes out of this episode is Obi-Wan suggesting they give Jar Jar some weapons training, so that we might finally have some justification was to why he's brought along on missions at all.

On the subject of character development, Storm of Ryloth seems to be all about that with an incredibly generic story about Ahsoka overreaching and losing some of her men, causing Anakin to try and teach her a lesson. And so he does. And she learns from it. That's the basic skeleton, and all that's really worth mentioning (though Wookiepedia has a surprisingly expansive plot synopsis for it all the same). This is one of those episodes it seems clear was thrown in at the last minute to make up for the missing episodes which became components of the film.

The Ryloth storyline carries over into two more episodes Innocents of Ryloth and Liberty on Ryloth, neither of which carry much significance, with the few notable highlights being the introduction of future Rebels character Hera Syndulla's father Cham and a cool moment of sound mixing when Mace Windu escapes a shut off bridge in Liberty, and a rather heartwarming ending moment in Innocents where some Clone Troopers who'd been looking after a young Twi'lek girl find out that her nickname for them, Nerra, translates to "brother". Ultimately, Innocents of Ryloth is a sweet if unremarkable episode, and Liberty on Ryloth is so pointlessly empty it stands out as perhaps the low point of season one.

But now lets all strap in for the finale, cause trust me, it's about to all pick and up reach near Hidden Enemy level here.


**** yes, Hostage Crisis.

I say that, because while other episodes have been riffs on cliched ideas and classic cinema, this episode blatantly rips off a revered film, and does so so brilliantly its utterly delightful. Ok, so you all remember Ziro the Hutt from the Clone Wars movie, right? You don't? Because I barely mentioned him? That's fair, but in my defense, he's awful. Just awful. Anyway, the Droopy Dog sounding uncle of Jabba who betrayed him to the Separatists has been arrested by the Republic. Boom, you're caught up.

Anyway, the gloriously badass looking Cad Bane (whose imposing bounty hunter demeanor calls to mind The Saint of Killers from Garth Ennis' Preacher, among other iconic characters) arrives at the senate building and is promptly the subject of an arrest attempt from senate commandos before Aurra Sing (remember her from the pod race scene in Episode I?) snipes them, and joins Bane and his bounty hunter crew on the senate's doorstep.

Meanwhile, up in Padme's office, Anakin tries to convince her to go away with him, to reconnect, but she's too focused on work, and worries he's going to slip up and reveal their secret marriage. Their relationship feels honest here, believable, sincere, more so than we've ever seen thus far. Anakin say some sweet sentiment about giving his lightsaber (his life, as he puts it) to her, when they're intruded upon by Senator Organa, who calls Padme down to discuss the Enhanced Privacy Invasion Bill (because in a galaxy far, far away, they don't sugar coat their bills with words like "Patriot Act") while Anakin hides under a desk. However, when all the senators are assembled, Cad Bane and his team capture them and hold them hostage within the building, which they lock down. They demand from Senator Palpatine that Ziro the Hutt, a political prisoner, be set free in exchange for the hostages' lives. But there's one thing they don't count on: Anakin Skywalker. Now, unseen but weaponless, this one man must do whatever he can, employ all of his cunning and training, in order to overtake the hostage takers and their maniacally calculating leader and rescue his estranged wife, and that's when it hits you.

This is Die Hard.

You guys. You guys. This is ****ing Die Hard.

Cad Bane is Hans Gruber, the Coruscant Senate is the Nakatomi building, Senator Philo is Ellis and Anakin is mother****ing Bruce god damned John McClaine Willis.

Yippee-Kai-May the Force Be With You, Mother****er!

Yeah, this episode is fantastic. And not just because its Die Hard in space (but mostly that. They even set explosive charges in the building). The characters feel real, their emotions feel honest. Anakin shines like he never has before, both his smoldering rage and his focused intensity, showcasing why he is considered "the chosen one". The action is thrilling, there's a real sense of suspense, and this new antagonist in Cad Bane not only brings a new sense of menace to the series that Ventress, after so many near defeats, had begun to lose, but finally brings that Western influence into the universe that had been more prominent in the original trilogy (namely Han Solo, sure, but the cowboy genre leaked into the galaxy far, far away in a lot of ways).

In the end, we get a cliffhanger, as Cad Bane escapes with the effeminate Eric Cartman in Hutt form. I'm sure we're due for a resolution in the early episodes of Season 2, and honestly, I can't wait to get to them. So is season 1 worth watching? Yeah, I'd say so. Even with the the rough patches that bookended The Hidden Enemy, there's still a lot of good in it, enough to get one really excited to see if they can hit those same highs, and more frequently, in the second season. Who knows which episodes will be of consequence down the line, which are helpful to the understanding of later events in the series, which makes it difficult to say which episodes to potentially skip (I'm having a hard time believing the science-fiction double feature nefarious scientist of Blue Shadow Virus will really be the crux of any future arcs, though), but I can definitely say what's worth seeking out if you want a taste of what this show can do right. Some folks would ignore the series because they don't wanna get "too involved", others will because its a "cartoon" or a "kids show", but show them Ambush, or Rookies. Let them see the darkness of Lair of Grievous, or the tension of The Hidden Enemy. Let them see the flickers of romance that crop up in Hostage Crisis and Destroy Malevolence. Folks who got any joy at all out of the prequels will relish in the fun and ferocity of Clone Wars at its finest. To paraphrase a classic character, to pass this show up would be a big mistake-y.


Well, next week I'll be back with the second season of Clone Wars, which means we've got a whole lot of binging to do. See you guys then!

Friday, September 18, 2015

Star Wars: The Clone Wars

Hey guys, new to the blog? Why not check out the mission statement here, and get caught up with Episode I here, and Episode II here.


The year is 2008. Indiana Jones and the Sex and the City girls returned to mixed results, Barack Obama, Joe the Plumber and Sarah Palin were all names we came to know, The Dark Knight and Wall-E redefined their genres, and I...honestly had no idea there was a new Star Wars movie coming out. And that's no fault of senior year partying or outgrowing the franchise. When compared to the 9 figures its predecessors had pulled in, the comparatively paltry $68 million proves quite a lot of people didn't know this ever happened at all. Not just "movie only" Star Wars fans, but a fair amount of people who even embraced the Clone Wars television show were unaware this film existed, and it was so critically lambasted upon release it even wound up on some "Worst of 2008" lists.

Well, after an intro like that, do we dare disturb this cartoon universe? I mean, it's considered canon, so let's take a look at Star Wars: The Clone Wars.


It's worth noting from the start that this "film" was never intended to be one at all. After the release of Revenge of the Sith, Warner Bros. began work on a computer animated Clone Wars television series. After showing George Lucas some early episodes on a big screen, he reportedly said "This is so beautiful, why don't we just go and use the crew and make a feature?", so what would have been the early episodes of season one of the show were quickly tied together to make a jaunty episodic feature, so hurriedly produced that Lucas Licensing was unable to secure many of the deals it typically would for a cinematic release, and ultimately this rushed production shows in the "finished" product.

If you're looking to avoid spoilers, now's your chance to turn back and watch the film unaffected.

We open with an unfamiliar Warner Bros. logo preceding Lucasfilm in place of the typical 20th Century Fox, a jarring feeling we're sure the get again when we see that famous star arc over Cinderella's castle. From there, the title appears, but a different arrangement of the famed John Williams theme plays, throwing us once more, so that by the time the anticipated title scroll is replaced by a narration from the prolific Tom Kane (best known as Mr. Herriman from Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends or the Professor from Powerpuff Girls), you just come to accept that this is a very different Star Wars.

The biggest complaint most critics had visually was that the characters, designed to look like the classic Gerry Anderson puppets of Thunderbirds and Fireball XL-5, looked like the puppets from Thunderbirds and Fireball XL-5. I'm sure there are gonna be some folks who don't dig the look. Personally I liked it. It wasn't as good as the character designs they were partly based on from the earlier Clone Wars series, but even acknowledging that gives us our biggest issue from a canonical perspective.



Look, I'm not gonna pretend I don't have strong feelings about the original Clone Wars. I mentioned it in the mission statement, and it was bound to come up again. Genndy Tartakovsky, creator of Dexter's Laboratory and the masterful Samurai Jack, crafted two animated miniseries to bridge Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith, following Anakin's ascension to Jedi Knight (including the ceremonial removal of his braid), the debut appearances of Asajj Ventress and future Revenge of the Sith antagonist General Grievous, and exploring the dark, brooding nature of Anakin Skywalker on the edge of his descent. It was a beautiful, artfully crafted set of series, and for whatever reason, the powers that be at Disney, when time came to perform the culling of the canon, deemed the inclusion of these series unnecessary, relegating them to the "Star Wars Legends" banner. Dipping into the officially canon Clone Wars, starting with this film (we'll see if it continues as the series progresses), references and allusions that necessitate knowledge of the original Tartakovsky work are abound, whether it be the sheer fact that the first shot after a flying starship is an assemblage that includes Count Dooku and an as yet canonically unknown General Grievous, just sorta chilling there, as though people should know who he is (sure, this film came out after Revenge of the Sith, so audiences would be familiar, but from a chrono-canonical perspective, Grievous would only be familiar to those who'd seen his titan-like entrance in the original Clone Wars), or Obi-
Wan and Ventress heavily alluding to past interactions from the earlier series in their dialogue later in the film. I'm sure some aspects of Star Wars lore now redacted are hard to detach from the official for some folks (ideas of the Old Republic based on KOTR or bloodlines from post-Jedi novels now wiped away), but its even more difficult when what's meant to be official canon is so heavily cemented in a foundation that's officially non-existent.


As for the film itself, it's initial introductory voice over, which goes beyond familiarizing one with the set-up from the previous film to actually walking one through plot points of the current film that won't even be addressed for the first third of the story, seems to abandon all cinematic intent by showing rather than telling. The story eventually finds a flow, but the very beginning of this new chapter in the Star Wars mythos treats us as though we've missed something already, and it needs to hurriedly catch us up, and it sets the audience off on the wrong foot to truly get into the story for a bit.

While Yoda, Chancellor Palpatine and Mace Windu (actually Samuel L. Jackson, not even sounding like himself) debate whether to send Jedi to recover the kidnapped son of Jabba the Hutt (yep apparently he's got a kid) in order to gain his support in the Clone Wars, Obi-Wan and Anakin engage in a battle with the Separatist army on the planet Christophsis (which is a real planet name now). We're introduced more properly to the clone army itself, whose leaders (particularly Rex and Cody) have their own distinct personalities, a nice touch that makes the battle more engaging. Indeed, for whatever can be said in derision of this film, it's battle scenes are an absolute blast, they can go comedic without going full Jar Jar, as when one of the troopers decides to punch a battle droid in the face, only to hurt his hand, but the action can still carry a lot of weight (just go to about 5:04 into the film, and you'll see a trooper get his helmet, if not his full head, blown off, pretty heavy for the fairly kiddish tone we've experienced). Indeed, as far as I'm concerned, the medium of animation allows everything that was digitally enhanced in the live action series, like the flips and intense lightsaber action, to feel more natural since it doesn't break from the film's reality of movement at all.

The Separatists retreat, and Obi-Wan speaks to Anakin about his anticipation, both for reinforcements and for the arrival of his new padawan. Anakin expresses a desire to never himself have to train a younger Jedi, and is near indignant when Obi-Wan suggests he should (for better or worse, the Anakin in this film differs greatly from the live action one, both in demeanor and expressiveness). Of course, what could have been a nice, quiet moment of character study (the kind Genndy would have relished in) becomes an opportunity for irony when in fact the padawan who arrives is intended for Anakin instead of Obi-Wan. The young Palawan's name is Ahsoka Tano, red skinned, thin, and rocking an outfit that would likely get her thrown out of a bible belt high school, but the Jedi Council apparently had no problem with, despite the fact that every youngling, padawan, knight and master we've encountered wears some type of robes. Sure, they made an exception for her, let's just roll with that (though the more they comment on just how young she is makes that tube top attire way less comfortable), but her constant indignity at being viewed as a "youngling" and her continually smart-ass jabs at her master, whom she calls "Sky-guy" teeter very close to the Amblin kid, not quite E.T. or Episode I Anakin, but let's say so close to John Connor in T2 that I swear she's gonna try and teach Anakin slang at some point, and it gets grating real fast.


Next we're introduced to the villains of the film, the hooded Asajj Ventress seeking guidance from her we assume master Count Dooku (voiced by Christopher Lee, who even ****ing kills it here) and eventually Darth Sidious, who both expound upon the plan to use the kidnapped Hutt baby as leverage to get the Hutts' support on the Outer Rim of the galaxy. Weird seeing Ventress without any formal introduction (her actual introduction, like Grievous', floating out in the ether called "Legends", perhaps chilling with Mara Jade and Grand Admiral Thrawn), and even for a series rooted in fairy tales, its strange seeing Machiavellian manipulator Darth Sidious up to such mustache twirling Dick Dastardly deeds as these.

Meanwhile, back on Christophsis (ughhhhhhh), the enemy forces have fired up an energy shield that's spreading closer and closer towards the Republic's troops, and Rex believes it will make things "damn near impossible" (surprising to hear that kind of language in a film that wastes such time on the childish "you're not my real dad" angst of Ahsoka), until Anakin, inspired by the exclamations of his padawan, derives a plan to get through the shield under cover of...metal, and Obi-Wan goes along with this, agreeing to stay behind with the troops and provide a diversion, leaving the fate of this battle up to his impulsive, erratic former student and his even more impulsive, even more erratic, literally just became a padawan student. So let's just make peace right now with the fact that, with generals like this, the war being entirely rigged by Palpatine is literally the only logical reason the Republic could emerge victorious.

So Anakin and Ahsoka crouch beneath some metal as seemingly the entire army passes them by, and making their way crouched towards the shield generator in order to deactivate it, Ahsoka complains she's tired of crouching and wants to stand. Then, the man who without batting an eye murdered an entire village of Tusken Raiders, argued with both his Jedi master and his protective charge/Senator/love interest continually and belligerently, gives in to her insanely dangerous request because...she's just so darn cute? So, the two stand up, still under the cover of the metal because...reasons, when they bump into a destroyer droid and make the entire sequence worth it by doing a fantastic halt-and-hack attack, decimating the droid, freeing the two to make their way to the shield generator.


Obi-Wan attempts to stall the opposing leader with the type of "casual conversation" over tea that would have been really fun to hear Ewan McGregor deliver, while Anakin and Ahsoka are set upon as soon as she plants the charges to destroy the generator. Anakin fights a few foes off, but Ahsoka saves the day with the kind of force powers she's far, far too good with to be just a first-day padawan. Ashoka shows herself to be almost as competent as Anakin "the Chosen One" Skywalker, in one of many ways the film erred on the side of convenience rather than in-world logic. Altogether, the film is far more concerned with setting up an engaging TV show than sticking to the world and rules of the films, with characters acting very different from their live action counter parts (at one point Obi-Wan says "Ok, Anakin, here's the story" and I cringe a little), sometimes to their detriment, others, like Anakin, perhaps for the better, as though this was how he was intended to be in the prequel trilogy, had the writing better communicated it.

After Jabba is delivered several severed heads of bounty hunters sent to recover his child from an abandoned monastery, he calls once more on the Republic to rescue his child, threatening in true Hutt fashion to turn to the Separatists should they refuse. Sending Anakin and Ahsoka to the monastery with a small battalion, we get our first real sense of the Separatist army, as we encounter battle droids of varying rank and, indeed, intelligence. Now, nothing thus far in the official canon has given any indication that battledroids even have varying intellects, or any degree of distinct personality, and the idea of turning a once formidable foe into comic relief is nine times out of ten a terrible idea, but I'll concede, I love me some idiot battledroids. Maybe its the overall lighter tone (severed heads aside) that allows this to be more forgivable, but their goofy antics here and throughout the film delighted me.

The Republic launches a full on assault on the monastic compound, accompanied not by the orchestral score we come to expect from the franchise, but rather an almost heavy metal guitar composition that gives the scene an extra jolt of energy, and everything from Ahsoka's rogue acrobatics to the gunnery ship that can climb walls is a hell of a lot of fun. The score shifts once again, now to an almost Massive Attack/Thievery Corporation style track as Anakin and Ahsoka enter the building, where they eventually find Jabba's infant child, who Ahsoka dubs "Stinky". After realizing they've been trapped by Asajj and her army, and that Dooku's plan is to deceive the Hutts into thinking the Jedi kidnapped the child (plus some scenes involving a misquotation in a hologram and the duo losing the baby only to find it again a moment later, neither of which are really worth even acknowledging in any larger sense), Anakin concludes they need to make an expedient escape back to Tatooine, and alerts Obi-Wan (on Tatooine to try and broker a treaty with the Hutts) to come help rescue them, while Ahsoka worries the baby Hutt is extremely ill.


Outside the monastery, Commander Rex and his squad are set upon by battledroids, one of whom Rex proceeds to punch in his robot face, grab his gun (still in the droid's hand, mind you) and shoot several others, because Commander Rex is a stone cold clone badass, while Anakin and Ahsoka flee an attacking Asajj Ventress on what I assume are the same dragon creatures Russell Crowe rode in Man of Steel. Shortly thereafter, Obi-Wan defeats Ventress in a cool but inconsequential duel that concludes in her escape, and Anakin and Ahsoka head to Tatooine in a stolen junker of a ship, wherein Ahsoka seeks out a way to help the baby Hutt whose name I refuse to type any further. It's not until this point in the film it hits me that a dying infant, even an alien one, is some pretty heavy s**t to put in a film mostly aimed at kids, but it's worth it, as it delivered to me my single favorite minor character, not only in this film, but perhaps in the whole franchise: Dr. Droid, whose beleaguered, disinterested tone delivers a holographic diagnosis to Ahsoka before stating, and I quote "Uh...if you have any more problems...::sigh::...call an actual doctor". Where is his spin-off comic, Marvel? You got room for Lando, but not the Aubrey Plaza of the Star Wars universe?

Long story short, they return the baby Hutt to Jabba, who agrees to ally with the Republic, and Dooku's plan is foiled. Yoda offers to place Ahsoka in the tutelage of Obi-Wan due to Anakin's initial reticence, but he relents, conceding he's taken a liking to the young padawan. Then they all face the camera in a wide shot, and the movie ends. Yep, just like that.


Sure, there's some parts we skipped over, some good (Christopher Lee's brilliant snarling delivery during his lightsaber duel), some bad (a subplot with Padme and an apparently gender-fluid and scheming relative of Jabba named Zito the Hutt), but all inconsequential. Which, quite frankly, this whole film is. It's not terrible, nor is it great. I certainly wasn't miserable watching it, and it never hits the plodding patches Episode I or II does, nor is anything, even Ahsoka's Amblin moments, truly insufferable. But as I find myself writing this, nothing that wasn't directly written in my notes has stuck with me besides some action beats involving Commander Rex or Count Dooku and some battledroid slapstick.

Is it worth watching? No. I mean, if you're a completist, sure. And perhaps, if you want the origin of how Ahsoka and Anakin came together. But the film feels like the middle chunk of a story, dropping you in the midst of something with no official beginning anyway, substituting a rushed narrative for actual set up. The film is generally forgotten now, as it pretty much was when it came out, with few promotional tie-ins due to its aforementioned rushed production schedule. In response to the rather flippant decision, the "afterthought", to make this collection of episodes into a theatrical film, the head of Lucas Licensing simply said "Sometimes George works in strange ways", and that was certainly the case here. I may revisit the film some day, as it was hardly a chore to get through or anything. Hell, the uninitiated with some curiosity (or those who've seen the series but not the film) are certainly welcome to check it out. Viewing it isn't discouraged, it's just (like the film itself), not necessary.


Next week, we're diving into the first season of the Clone Wars television series, so check back in September 25th for that. Until then, I've got some binge watching to do, and some new formatting to determine, so feel free to chime in in the comments for now.

Friday, September 11, 2015

Star Wars Episode II: Attack of the Clones

Hey, if it's your first time here, feel free to check out the mission statement here, and the coverage of Episode 1 here.


The year is 2002. The WWF was now the WWE, Michael Jackson dangled a baby out of a window, America was on the precipice of picking Kelly Clarkson as the first American Idol, and folks' expectations, while tempered, were growing for the newest installation of the prequel trilogy. Things had changed vastly in the three years since the sci-fi/fantasy series had released Phantom Menace, mainly that fantasy had overtaken sci-fi. Wizards and heroes were all the rage, with Harry Potter and The Lord of the Rings conquering the box office (not to mention the debut of a certain web-slinger just a few weeks prior to this film's premiere), unlike when its predecessor duked it out with The Matrix, The Mummy and James Bond. In three years, it became a very different world, worried less about Y2K and more about terror, cassette gave way to CD, and a new experiment in cinema called "digital projection" was being toyed with. In fact, film's forever tinkerer George Lucas had announced that an additional shot of the film could only be seen if you saw it digital projection. Not that it wasn't already the top of my must-see list, but now I knew: "I have to see that in digital projection" I said (and knowing I once said that makes me cringe to this day). So see it I did, several times. In 35mm, in digital projection (turns out, it was a shot of Anakin's hand. That was it). For friend's birthday parties, for whatever the awkward pre-teen equivalent of a hang out is, weekends with the family. And yet, like many of you out there, there's very little I remembered about this oft-derided film besides the existence of Count Dooku and a scene in an arena.

Therefor, I'd wager it's about time for a refresher course, so let's talk about Attack of the Clones:


Have you ever seen half of a great movie? Now, I'm not talking seeing half of Citizen Kane on cable. I'm talking about seeing a full, feature length film, half of which is a thrilling mix of Blade Runner and Ben Hur, and half a poorly written, worse acted soap opera? Well, if you haven't, stop reading now, because clearly you haven't seen Attack of the Clones yet, and there's gonna be spoilers abound.

Now, there's two schools of thought on this film, that are simply the converse of one another: You're either "Sure, the stuff with Obi-Wan, Dooku and Palpatine was cool, but the stuff with Anakin and Padme was awful" against the film, or you're "Sure, the stuff with Anakin and Padme was awful, but the stuff with Obi-Wan, Dooku and Palpatine was so cool" for it. Myself, I've fallen into the latter camp on this one, and it's really hard not to.

We open with an assassination attempt on the now Senator Amidala which involves a god damned ship exploding, so we've already beaten out pretty much all the action in Phantom Menace already. Padme, who still apparently has decoys at this point, rushes to the dying body of the one currently posing as her, as the decoy exclaims that she's failed Padme by...doing precisely what she was meant to, taking the hit intended for the actual Senator (by the end of this film, you've either abandoned trying to make sense of it in a derisive huff, or come to accept that this universe has a logic entirely its own). Inside the office of Chancellor Palpatine, some Jedi have assembled to discuss how to move forward knowing Amidala is still the subject of much scorn amongst the seedier corners of the galaxy, and so they offer to assign her a body guard, which Amidala, arriving with her entourage including a now much more reserved and silent Jar Jar Binks, is reticent to accept until they conclude that her former companion Obi-Wan Kenobi should be the one assigned to her. It's been a long time since they've seen one another, and since she's seen Obi-Wan's apprentice Anakin. Indeed, Amidala appears to have aged to about 16 or so, while Anakin...has become at least 19, really, honestly. Oh, and Obi-Wan has a beard and long hair now. It's...anybody throwing water on the "Ezra is Kylo Ren" theory because the age difference in appearance isn't believable had best revisit the first two prequels to see how little of a s**t they give. Hell, they don't even bother to attempt aging secondary characters like Mace Windu.

Yep, totally looks like they've aged the same amount of time.
Anyway, the trio are reunited (after being greeted at the door, with one of his handful of lines, by Jar Jar), and there's some lingering talk of how much Anakin has grown which, with better writing and chemistry between the two leads, could have made the audience feel a romantic tension between Padme and Anakin instead of feeling like somebody was trying really hard to tell you there's romantic tension between the two when there really isn't. It's hard to tell whose fault the dead weight of the Anakin/Padme interactions are, but due to little flickers you see later in this film, as well as Revenge of the Sith (which we'll get to in...jesus, 8 weeks? Why am I doing this to myself?), I know it's not the popular opinion, but these two are good actors who can really hit certain emotional cues when not weighed down by really uncomfortably robotic dialogue. Sure, they don't have the McDiarmid/McGregor/Lee caliber ability to sell almost any line in front of them, but in silent moments the two can deliver really powerful performances, so I'm afraid the fault really lies with the script on this one.

Meanwhile, a mysterious Mandalorian armored figure tasks a veiled, purple attired woman with something as cars fly past in a dark city sky, very Blade Runner-esque. As you'll see throughout the film, Clones has the advantage over Menace in it's sheer cinematic nature. The idea of tone, of shot choice and lighting, of ambience and atmosphere, of using set pieces not just to dazzle but evoke emotion, its clear these become a priority to George after his much-panned previous endeavor. Or maybe he had just shaken off the cobwebs with Menace (remember, he hadn't directed anything before that since the original Star Wars), and after flexing the basic filmmaking muscles three years prior, he was ready to get more into the advanced. Whatever the reason, it's clear Lucas had stepped away from Amblin kid simplicity, and fell more in line with the darker, more low-key lighting and murky atmosphere of film noir and James Bond.


Indeed, we see that James Bond influence strong when, as Anakin and Obi-Wan bicker about the best way to look after Padme (Anakin wants to find the attempted assailant, Obi-Wan just wants to protect her), the purple clothed woman (whose name, by the way, is Zam Wessel, thought originally she was intended to be Aura Sing, from that shot during the podrace in Phantom Menace) sends a robot to cut through the glass and delivering two presumably poisonous insects into Padme's room while she sleeps (a la the tarantula in Dr. No). Anakin and Obi-Wan both sense it through the Force and charge into the room, Anakin killing both with his lightsaber while Obi-Wan, and I'm sorry to go bold for this, but it needs to be emphasized, jumps out of a god damned window and rides a ****ing flying robot through a Blade Runner cityscape. Honestly, you could stop the movie right there, and I'd be good, but this kicks off one of the most imaginative and thrilling sci-fi/action sequences in the entire franchise, as Anakin steals a ship to try and catch up with Obi-Wan.

Here we get some snarky banter on par with the type Han would throw at Luke or Leia when Obi-Wan asks "What took you so long?" and the two go at it for a bit, showing Lucas can convey a believable relationship through dialogue, just not a romantic one. It's fun to watch Anakin and Obi-Wan together, their relationship less the mentor/mentee paternal one of Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan, and more one between an impulsive younger brother and the older, more supervisorial sibling, and even when you know what's coming next through dialogic cues, Lucas (like Spielberg and the rest of their ilk) knows how to make the cliched feel classic, as Obi-Wan complaining they've lost Wessel leads to Anakin leaping from the ship to land on hers, and McGregor even following it up with a cop show/comic book movie ol' stand by of "I hate it when he does that".

In another brilliantly pulse-pounding moment, Anakin causes Zam's ship to crash land, but she escapes into a building. Informing Obi-Wan, who finally catches up to Anakin with a quip of "Why do I have a feeling you'll be the death of me?", that he believes Wessel to be a shape shifter, Obi-Wan urges caution and keeping a low profile as they entire a seedy and exciting set piece, the murky sports bar whose design and decor abandons the whimsy of Mos Eisley in favor of a much more damp blue dreg of a dive, more fitting the tone the film is (mostly, as we'll see) going for. While Anakin searches the place, Obi-Wan finds a spot at the bar to observe more covertly, and we're treated to perhaps the single best scene in all of the prequels, the most true to the original series, the "Death Sticks" sequence.


Finally locating Zam and chasing her out into an alley to interrogate her (you almost feel like they're going to rough her up too, or shout at her a la Popeye Doyle in The French Connection), all she can say is she was hired by a bounty hunter before being killed by a poisoned dart, and we get our first real look at one of the two candidates for the "big bad" of this film, Jango Fett, in full Mandalorian glory as he flies away from the scene. Returning to Coruscant, the Jedi council states that they must find the attempted assailants, meaning Anakin was right when arguing with Obi-Wan. The more matured filmmaking and storytelling skills on display would suggest Lucas meant that, as though to convey the teenager-esque Anakin's break from Obi-Wan and subsequent youthful, angsty rebellion as the result of that pivotal moment in a young kid's life when they start being right and their parents wrong. But, then again, after the last film, it could just as likely be that this change of plans happens for the sake of convenience, and to simply move the plot forward. Either way, Obi-Wan has now been assigned to hunt down the source of these attacks, while Anakin has been assigned sole guard duty of Amidala, who demands to be brought back to Naboo, despite Anakin's arguing otherwise, in a scene that could have showed both of their headstrong attitudes and maybe some It Happened One Night romantic tension if the dialogue hadn't read like some freshman year film school assignment.

Padme delegates her Senatorial powers to Jar Jar Binks because of course, and Obi-Wan finds himself in a robot space diner run by a greasy, obese mustached alien, which is my favorite sentence to have ever typed. Obi-Wan is sent in the direction of a planet called Kamino, and here our narrative diverges, as we cut between Obi-Wan's stellar noir-style search for answers, and Anakin and Padme's necessary but lifeless love story, so rather than jump back and forth, let's just start with the better of the two.


Obi-Wan makes his way back to the Jedi Temple library (a gorgeous set-piece you can actually visit, since it's almost identical to the Long Hall at the Trinity College Library in Dublin), but discovers Kamino is nowhere to be found in the Jedi records. Despite the librarian's insistence that if something isn't in the Temple records, it doesn't exist, Obi-Wan seeks out Yoda, whose in the midst of instructing a group of younglings, in an adorable sequence that proves, contrary to what Episode I would have you believe, that kids can be adorable in Star Wars as long as you're not trying to make them be. Posing the query before the students, one suggests that the absence of Kamino is due to someone erasing it from the records, and since the film has already addressed a former Jedi named Count Dooku, you get a sense who it might have been. You know, it's like Chekhov's lightsaber. Eventually, Obi-Wan finds the coordinates for Kamino and makes his way to a rainy landing platform at a strange facility where a gorgeously computer animated Kaminoan greets him saying he's been expected. Come on, a dark, rainy ominous science facility that was expecting the unannounced Obi-Wan on a planet mysteriously erased from Jedi records which is linked to the assassination of an attempted assassin? The sheer espionage and intrigue, how are you not on board for this film all the way? (Oh, right, the other half of the narrative. We'll get there.)

Discovering that the facility has been creating a clone army superior to any battle droid at the instruction of a long deceased Jedi named Sifo-Dyas, Obi-Wan inquires as to the source of the clones, where we formally meet Jango Fett and his clone-son Boba (all the other clones go through an adanvced aging process, but Fett asked for one at a normal age rate to act as his child, because it all needed to be tied into a fan favorite character of little real consequence because...reasons). Reporting back to the Jedi Council about the clones, Obi-Wan deduces that Jango was the bounty hunter he's been searching for, and chases him through space in one of the best thrill-rides the prequels deliver, complete with asteroid tunnels, sonic explosions in space and even an homage to Empire Strikes Back with Obi-Wan attaching his ship to the back of an asteroid. He follows Fett to the planet of Geonosis, another brilliantly designed planet and race of creatures, where he discovers Count Dooku is working with the Trade Federation (made up of a Geonosian, a strange but engaging android-like alien, and the two Neimoidians from the first film who you sort of grow to hate by this one, their Mickey Rooney Asian accents and general ineffectualness becoming more prominent in this installment), to build an army of battle droids to take on the Republic, as well as arranging Padme's assassination attempts. Obi-Wan sends out a transmission attempting to warn the Republic and the Jedi, but is captured midway through.


Meanwhile, checking in with the couple who has all the believable deep romantic love of a shotgun wedding, we're treated to a string of dialogue meant to either convey character development or a budding relationship, achieving neither, but rather painting (with a wide, wide ****ing brush) Anakin's teenager-esque tendencies, and the idea that though they apparently love each other, they can't be together because the Jedi forbid romantic entanglements (probably discouraged in those letters from St. Paul of Tarkin **rim shot**). We arrive on Naboo (where, side note, the architecture and costumes seem really out there and sci-fi, but their luggage looks like Samsonite. I'm just saying), they talk, share a really uncomfortable kiss, and then Anakin has a nightmare premonition about his mother in a scene that manages to be the least believable thing in a movie about space wizards. He and Padme head to Tatooine where they run into C-3PO again because...reasons, and Anakin confronts Watto, whose new facial hair and attire seem hellbent on confirming those anti-semitism complaints from the first film, from whom Anakin finds out his mother was bought by and then married to a man named Cliegg Larrs. Anakin seeks out Larrs, and meets his half-brother Owen and his girlfriend (who he addresses as "girlfriend", the only time the word is used in the series, and it feels really jarring to hear it) Beru, who reveal to Anakin that his mother was captured by Tusken Raiders, and while Anakin going to find his mom is probably the most significant plot point you forgot was in this film, seeing the passion in his face as he rides that speeder bike into the desert gives serious creedence to the idea that the script is holding this kid back, and his tear-filled reaction to his dying mother, and the rage with which he slaughters the Tuscan Raiders afterwards (a scene that should have been so much longer) confirms it. Returning to Padme and confessing that he "killed them all", we can see just about the point Natalie Portman checks out of the film, as they're both forced to utter lines like "I will even learn to stop people from dying" that even Laurence Olivier couldn't pull off. After a funeral for Shmi Skywalker, eulogized by Cliegg, who is hands down the most grizzled character in all of Star Wars lore, Anakin and Padme intercept the transmission from Obi-Wan and, realizing it would take too long for the Jedi to reach Obi-Wan in time, decide to attempt a rescue themselves, flying off, 3PO in tow, to Geonosis.

Remember how I mentioned that even Olivier couldn't pull off certain lines? We're about to spend a little time with people who could. First, an assemblage of delegates, including Jimmy Smitts as the future adoptive father of Princess Leia Organa, discuss using the now-come-to-light clone army to combat the droid masses on Geonosis and fight back the increasingly dangerous Separatist forces, but in order to do that, Palpatine asserts, he'd need to be granted emergency power. Palpatine convinces the Naboo proxy-Senator, Jar Jar Binks, to deliver an impassioned speech in support of emergency power being granted to the Chancellor, when McDiarmid gets the chance to let out a victorious acceptance monologue, he shows Lucas could have handed him a phone book or worse, and he still could capture your attention and ignite your imagination.


Speaking of folks who could read a phone book, Obi-Wan is captured by Saruman...I mean Dracula...I mean Scaramanga...I mean f**k I miss him so much. Christopher Lee as Count Dooku is one of the absolute highlights of this film and indeed this whole prequel endeavor, delivering every line with the kind of grandiose gravitas it needs, understanding the theatrical, operatic quality of this fantasy and playing into it brilliantly. His villainous banter taking on Ewan McGregor's best Alec Guinness is one of the most magnificent things in Clones, and even later lines like "It is obvious that this contest cannot be decided by our knowledge of the Force, but by our skills with a lightsaber" that would have been atrocious on any other actor's tongue sound so gloriously badass from one of the greatest cinematic villain actors.

Landing on Geonosis, C-3PO is united with R2-D2, and their bickering ensues almost immediately, as does 3PO's stiff bumbling. As Anakin and Padme fight off cave-dwelling Geonosians and fall onto the conveyor belt of a droid factory, the two affable droids stumble their way through it all, proving that we'll gladly accept fumbles and puns a la Jar Jar ("I'm beside myself", "This is a real drag") if they're delivered by the right character, and perhaps because while 3PO himself could probably get annoying, the Abbott to his Costello is there on the scene flying around with jets and generally saving the day for the usually-kickass-but-in-this-scene helpless Amidala. When you look into the making of the film and find out this conveyor belt sequence was tacked on later to "improve the pacing", it comes as no surprise. The scene is of no consequence to the rest of the film, adds nothing to the development of any characters, and short of a few cheap thrills honestly slows down the story. It's not Anakin and Padme sitting in a Naboo field sharing their feelings dragging, but it certainly doesn't help things.


The human duo are captured, and share some could-have-been-good love dialogue before being wheeled into the coliseum, another stunning set piece which leads to more delightfully snarky dialogue between Anakin and Obi-Wan as they're being chained to large stone pillars. Quickly regaining her sense of action, Padme climbs atop the pillar while Anakin and Obi-wan just dangle and bicker, reclaiming her role as the badass some of us really loved in the last film, and the moment when, once somewhat freed from chains, Padme leaps aboard the creature Anakin has lassoed and kisses him on the cheek is not only her most believable romantic moment in the film, but its a genuinely endearing scene that shows the two have viable chemistry when its not being forced through words.

A series of imaginative creatures are released that the trio fend off in the absolute highlight of the movie. Chain flailing and gladiatorial combat and high flying flips ensue before the coliseum is set upon by an army of Jedi and clone troopers, all under the watchful gaze of a brooding Count Dooku, two panicked Neimoidians, and the soon called into action Jango Fett. Boba watches as his father tries to take the field, but to paraphrase a famous song, the Jedi there refused to yield. It's an epic slaughter, on par with the coliseum sequence from Season 5 Game of Thrones, and almost approaching its level of violence when SLJ's Mace Windu straight up beheads Jango Fett, in full view for Boba and the audience, leading in the greatest toy in cinema history, the Jango Fett with magnetic head from Hasbro.

Escaping the coliseum, the trio chase down Count Dooku to a different facility while Yoda leads the clone troops in the utter destruction of all the Geonosian forces. In the midst of the action, Padme is knocked from the ship, along with a clone trooper, and falls upon the sand. Anakin demands they turn the ship around and land it to rescue her, and Obi-Wan insists there's no time, they have to get to Dooku, and that Anakin cannot let his personal feelings get in the way, an argument that would carry a lot more weight if they weren't referring to an actual Senator who they'd just abandoned in the middle of an active war zone with only one soldier at her side, and who they were specifically assigned to protect, whose been the subject of two assassination attempts by the very people they've now stranded her in the midst of, virtually unattended. You know, that's twice this film Obi-Wan's blatantly misunderstood what their job was, and when you tack on getting intellectually bested by a youngling, the fact that he'll think the best hiding place for himself and Anakin's son iss on Anakin's home planet, with his own family makes a lot more sense.


Dooku is attempting to flee with the Separatists plans for an ultimate weapon, a spherical ship that can seemingly destroy planets, which he intends to bring to his master, Darth Sidious. Obi-Wan and Anakin track him down, and foolhardily charging in, Anakin is quickly cast aside with force lightning as Dooku (with my favorite lightsaber design in the entire series) battles it out with Obi-Wan, whose  simply no match for him. As Dooku prepares to deliver the death blow, Anakin leaps in and, with both his own blade and Obi-Wan's, performs some of the most exhilarating combat in the entire film before losing one blade and ultimately his hand. About to escape, Dooku is once more set upon, this time by Yoda, with whom he engages in a surprisingly entertaining Force battle that Lee brings an impressive level of conviction to, before delivering the aforementioned "skills with a lightsaber" line, as the tiny green creature goes toe to toe with the Count in a flipping, extravagant lightsaber duel that's both absurd and viscerally enthralling. Knowing he cannot win, Dooku manages to escape, leaving the Republic and their Jedi to count their losses, consider their victories and plan ahead.

Back on Coruscant, Dooku delivers the plans to Darth Sidious, who suggest the creation and use of a clone army was part of his plan all along. The Jedi council laments that, after years of peace in the Republic, the Clone Wars have begun, and fear what lies ahead.

Meanwhile, the final shot of the film isn't troopers marching off to war or some grand ceremony, but parallels Empire Strikes Back's dour, reserved finale, as Padme and Anakin wed on Naboo, witnessed by the two droid companions, and (if you saw it in digital), Anakin's metallic hand clasps hers. The film has done so little to establish their relationship as believable, and I don't know if it was the sweeping John Williams score, or just the pair's silent expression, but I found this scene quite moving, and a fitting conclusion to the film. The way they look into each other's eyes with an almost Graduate-esque sense of uncertainty is genuinely beautiful, and the two share a genuine connection, finally tenable as pair of "star-crossed lovers" unsure of why they're doing this, or whether they should, just knowing they want to.


And that's where they leave us, setting up both the conclusion of another trilogy, on the precipice of not one but two destructive wars, and igniting the flights of fancy that would eventually create two Clone Wars television series (though only one "really" happened, apparently). I didn't have terribly fond memories of this film, and had friends who swore up and down it was the worst in the franchise, but I have to be honest, I enjoyed myself. I may be sounding like June on an episode of HDTGM, but I had a blast, and found the film totally engaging, tonally well-conceived, and was able to look past the dragging chunks of Anakin, which was impossible to do in the first film.

I'm sure some folks feel differently, and I'll gladly welcome the discussion, but in terms of "Is it worth watching?" I would not only say yes, I'd suggest anyone thrown by this somewhat glowing review of an oft-derided film revisit it before you cast scorn and derision towards it, especially if it's been years since you've last seen it. In the wake of political allegory in dark fantasy like Game of Thrones, The Dark Knight and Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Attack of the Clones feels more connected with today's cultural landscape than the quivering, recovering, longing for the fantastic and distracting world of 2002, and its maturity compared to its predecessor may be more recognized now that we, the likely previously juvenile viewers, have reached our own.

We'll be taking a break from the live action for a little while (for eight weeks, to be exact) as we dive into The Clone Wars, starting with the 2008 theatrical film that launched it all, so check back in on September 18th for that, and until then feel free to chime in in the comments.